Applying Acrylic Sealer Over Penetrating Sealer: Is It Possible?

When it comes to sealing concrete floors, it's essential to choose the right type of sealer for the job. If your floor already has a penetrating sealer, you may be wondering if it's possible to apply an acrylic sealer over it. This is because the two types of sealers work differently and have different properties. A penetrating sealer is designed to protect the surface of the concrete, while an acrylic or urethane sealer is designed to penetrate into the pores of the concrete and provide a more durable and long-lasting seal.

Can You Reapply Concrete Sealer?

Applying acrylic sealer over a penetrating sealer is a common question among concrete sealer enthusiasts. The answer to this question depends on a few important factors. Firstly, it’s crucial to determine whether the previous sealer used is compatible with the acrylic sealer you intend to apply. If the previous sealer is a solvent-based acrylic sealer and the new sealer is also solvent-based, then there shouldnt be any issues in resealing without removing the previous sealer.

One method to remove the previous sealer is through acid etching. Acid etching involves applying a diluted acid solution to the concrete surface, which helps to strip off the old sealer. Another option is grinding, where a grinder is used to mechanically remove the existing sealer.

Removing the previous sealer is crucial because applying a new sealer over an incompatible one can lead to poor adhesion and a less durable coating. The new sealer may not bond properly with the underlying sealer, resulting in a weak and easily compromised surface.

It’s worth noting that reapplying concrete sealer is generally recommended to maintain the protection and aesthetic appearance of the concrete. Over time, the original sealer may wear off due to foot traffic, weather exposure, or other factors. By resealing, you can restore the protective layer and enhance the concretes durability, resistance to stains, and overall longevity.

However, if the previous sealer isn’t compatible, it’s crucial to remove it through acid etching or grinding before applying the new sealer.

Pros and Cons of Using Acid Etching to Remove Old Sealers

  • Effective in removing old sealers
  • Can be done on various surfaces such as concrete, stone, and tile
  • Helps to prepare the surface for resealing or applying a new coating
  • Provides a thorough cleaning by removing dirt, stains, and contaminants
  • Can enhance the adhesion of new sealers or coatings
  • Can be a cost-effective method compared to other removal techniques
  • Allows for better penetration of new sealers for improved performance
  • May require the use of protective equipment and precautions due to the corrosive nature of the acid
  • Requires proper ventilation and disposal methods to prevent harm to the environment
  • May cause discoloration or damage to certain delicate surfaces
  • If not done correctly, can result in an uneven or rough surface
  • May not be suitable for all types of sealers or coatings

If the original sealer was water-based, you’ve the flexibility to use either a solvent-based or water-based sealer for resealing. However, it’s important to determine the type of sealer previously applied before proceeding.

Can You Put Water-Based Sealer Over Water-Based Sealer?

If the original sealer was a water-based sealer, applying a new sealer on top of it’s indeed possible. You can choose to use either a solvent-based or water-based sealer for this purpose. However, it’s important to ensure that the new sealer is compatible with the old sealer and that proper surface preparation is carried out before applying the new sealer.

Before proceeding with applying a new sealer, it’s recommended to clean the surface thoroughly to remove any dirt, dust, or contaminants. This can be done by using a mild detergent and water, or by using a suitable cleaning solution recommended by the sealer manufacturer.

On the other hand, if you opt for a water-based sealer as the new coat, ensure that it’s compatible with the existing water-based sealer. Some manufacturers may recommend using a specific primer or bonding agent to ensure proper adhesion between the old and new sealer layers.

Regardless of the type of sealer you choose, always read and follow the manufacturers instructions for application, including recommended dry times and curing periods. It’s also a good idea to test the sealer on a small, inconspicuous area before applying it to the entire surface, to ensure that it achieves the desired results.

Differences Between Solvent-Based and Water-Based Sealers

  • Solvent-based sealers are typically made with chemicals that evaporate into the air, while water-based sealers are made mostly with water.
  • Solvent-based sealers tend to have a stronger odor and require more ventilation during application, whereas water-based sealers have a milder scent and are generally more environmentally friendly.
  • Solvent-based sealers often provide a glossy finish, while water-based sealers offer a range of finishes including matte, satin, and high-gloss.
  • Solvent-based sealers generally penetrate deeper into the substrate, providing greater protection against stains and wear, whereas water-based sealers may not penetrate as deeply but still offer good protection.
  • Solvent-based sealers typically have a longer cure time, meaning it takes longer for them to fully dry and cure, while water-based sealers often have a faster cure time.
  • Application methods may differ between solvent-based and water-based sealers, with solvent-based sealers typically requiring a brush or roller, while water-based sealers can often be applied by spraying or with a brush or roller.
  • Solvent-based sealers may be more suitable for outdoor applications, as they tend to be more resistant to UV damage and harsh weather conditions, while water-based sealers may be better suited for indoor use.
  • Clean-up is typically easier with water-based sealers, as they can be cleaned with soap and water, whereas solvent-based sealers often require special solvents or cleaners.
  • Costs can vary between solvent-based and water-based sealers, with solvent-based options generally being more expensive upfront, but may require fewer coats for desired results, while water-based sealers are often more affordable but may require more coats.
  • It’s important to carefully read and follow the manufacturer’s instructions for both solvent-based and water-based sealers to ensure proper application and achieve the desired results.

After applying the first coat of concrete sealer, it’s important to wait before applying the second coat. This allows the sealer to properly dry and bond with the surface. To achieve an even coverage, it’s recommended to apply the second coat in the opposite direction to the first. The waiting time for the second coat can vary depending on the specific product, but typically the manufacturer will recommend waiting two to four hours. This waiting period ensures optimal results and helps to protect and enhance the appearance of the concrete surface.

How Long to Wait Before Applying Second Coat of Concrete Sealer?

When it comes to applying a second coat of concrete sealer, timing is crucial. To achieve the best results, it’s important to wait for the proper amount of time before applying the second coat. This will ensure that the sealer adheres properly and provides maximum protection to the surface.

This will ensure even coverage and prevent any missed spots or uneven application. By applying the second coat in this manner, you can be confident that the entire surface is adequately protected.

It’s worth noting that the specific drying and curing times may vary depending on the type of sealer being used.

The Importance of Proper Surface Preparation Before Applying Concrete Sealer

Proper surface preparation is crucial before applying a concrete sealer. Without it, the sealer may not adhere effectively and could lead to inadequate protection. Concrete surfaces should be clean, dry, and free from any contaminants like dust, dirt, oil, or grease. It’s recommended to remove any existing sealer or coatings before applying a new one. The surface should also be repaired, if necessary, to ensure it’s smooth and even. Taking the time to properly prepare the surface will help to ensure a successful application and the desired results.

Source: How to Seal Concrete – Sealing Concrete in 7 Steps

However, there are instances where it’s possible to layer sealers if they’re compatible and applied correctly.

Can You Put Different Sealers on Top of Each Other?

When it comes to applying sealers on top of each other, it’s crucial to understand the compatibility of different types of sealers. In particular, combining a solvent-based sealer with a water-based sealer can lead to disaster. The solvents present in the solvent-based sealer have the potential to eat away or soften the water-based sealer, resulting in the deterioration of both coatings.

Moreover, it’s important to note that each type of sealer is designed to work optimally on it’s own. Therefore, it’s best to follow the manufacturers instructions and recommendations while choosing and applying sealers. This will help ensure the longevity and effectiveness of the sealing products.

This can be done by using a suitable stripping agent, following proper safety precautions.

By taking the time to thoroughly prepare the surface and applying the appropriate sealer according to the manufacturers guidelines, you can achieve the best possible outcome.

They’re a great option for many projects and offer excellent durability and protection. However, if you do need to switch from a water-based sealer to an acrylic sealer, it’s best to remove the water-based sealer first before applying the acrylic sealer. This will ensure the best results and prevent any potential issues.

Can I Use Acrylic Sealer Over Water Based Sealer?

In fact, they offer many benefits such as being environmentally friendly, easy to clean up, and low in odor. However, if you’re looking to apply an acrylic sealer over a water-based sealer, it’s important to proceed with caution.

One option is to remove the water-based sealer completely before applying the acrylic sealer. This can be a time-consuming and labor-intensive process, but it ensures that you start with a clean slate. You can do this by using a solvent-based stripper or by mechanically grinding the surface.

This involves applying a small amount of the acrylic sealer over a small, inconspicuous area of the surface and letting it dry completely. Then, check if the two sealers have bonded well and if there are any signs of blistering or peeling.

They may have specific recommendations or guidelines for using their products together.

Overall, while it’s generally not recommended to apply a solvent-based sealer over a water-based sealer, there are some potential solutions. However, it’s important to carefully consider the potential risks and to conduct compatibility tests before proceeding with this method.

The Process of Removing a Water-Based Sealer Before Applying an Acrylic Sealer

  • Prepare the surface by cleaning it with water and a mild detergent.
  • Use a pressure washer or a scraper to remove any loose or peeling sealer.
  • Apply a chemical sealer stripper to the surface.
  • Allow the stripper to sit for the recommended amount of time.
  • Use a scraper or a stiff brush to scrub off the sealer.
  • Rinse the surface thoroughly with water to remove any residue.
  • Allow the surface to dry completely before applying the acrylic sealer.
  • Apply the acrylic sealer according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
  • Allow the sealer to dry and cure properly before using the surface.


If you’ve a penetrating sealant, it’s crucial to remove it before applying another chemical seal coat. This is because a penetrating sealer only protects the surface of the old concrete and doesn’t penetrate into it’s pores like acrylic or urethane sealers can.

Scroll to Top